Ethical dilemma of identity disclosure faced by medical students in clinical clerkships: A nationwide multicenter study in China.
Zhao Y., Cao Y., Che L., Fu Q., Song S., Zhao B., Zhang S., Zhang W., Li X., Choi S., Zhao J., Zhang H., Li Y., Xu H., Pan H.
ObjectiveMedical students in China are currently facing a dilemma of whether to clarify their identity as students to patients. Further investigation is needed to support policy-making. The aim was to identify factors influencing medical students' decision on whether or not to clarify their identity to patients and to examine the effects of their decision.MethodsThe study was a cross-sectional nationwide multicenter survey consisting of 947 medical students. A self-designed questionnaire was composed of 19 structured questions investigating the present situation and participants' perception of the ethical dilemma surrounding medical student identity. The questionnaires were distributed randomly in teaching hospitals affiliated with 13 medical schools across China from June 2015 to January 2016.ResultsA total of 947 valid questionnaires were retrieved with a valid response rate of 83.7%. Most medical students (71.4%) tended to be ambiguous about their student identity in front of patients. The frequency of encountering distrust and patients' or patient relatives' refusal to allow students to perform procedures was significantly lower for students who explicitly stated their identity than for those who were ambiguous about their identity (p<0.001). Less experience in clinical rotations (<0.5 y/0.5-1 y, OR 2.7, 95% CI 1.7-4.3; <0.5 y/>1 y, OR 3.6, 95% CI 2.0-6.5), preceptors' straightforward introduction of the students (OR 8.7, 95% CI 5.4-13.8) and students' acknowledgment of patients' right to know (OR 2.3, 95% CI 1.2-4.5) were related to students' clear self-introduction to patients.ConclusionIt is beneficial for medical students to clearly explain their identity to patients in order to decrease patient distrust and prevent the refusal to have certain appropriate procedures performed. Several methods, including emphasizing the role of mentors, developing curriculum for medical students, and creating clear regulations and guidelines for revealing the identity of medical students on the healthcare team can help address and ideally resolve this ethical dilemma of identity disclosure.